WellPrept
Decision Aid

BPH: choosing a treatment

An enlarged prostate has more ways to treat it than almost any other men's health problem. This page compares the five main paths, from doing nothing to a full surgery.

Last reviewed 2026-05-24 Reading time ~8 min Print-friendly
A note before you start

This tool does not pick for you. Your urologist will help you choose.

Use what is below to sort your own priorities before your visit: how much your symptoms bother you, how much you want to protect your sex life, and how much down time you can take. Your urologist knows your prostate size, your health, and your International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), a survey that scores how bad your urine symptoms are. They can match these options to your situation.

Chapter 1 · The decision

What this decision is about

Benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) is the slow growth of the prostate gland that many men have by their 60s and 70s. As the prostate gets bigger, it can squeeze the channel that urine flows through. The result is a weaker stream, more trips to the bathroom, and waking up at night.

There are many ways to treat it. The choice is usually about which step fits you right now, with the option to move up later if symptoms get worse.

What your urologist brings to the choice

Your urologist weighs many things at once: how bothered you are (your IPSS score), how big your prostate is, the shape of the gland (since some shapes rule out some procedures), how well your bladder still empties, your overall health, and what you most want to keep, whether that is sex life, short down time, or no daily pills. They will tell you which options fit your prostate.

Chapter 2 · The five steps

Compare the five main paths

Columns run from least to most invasive. Many men start at step one or two and stay there for years.

Step 1Watch & lifestyle Step 2Pills Step 3Office procedures Step 4OR procedures Step 5Open or robotic surgery
What it is Yearly check-ins. Fluid timing, less evening caffeine and alcohol, treating constipation, double-voiding, weight loss if needed. Daily medicines. Alpha blockers relax the muscle. 5-alpha reductase inhibitors (5-ARIs) shrink the gland. Tadalafil daily helps flow and erections. Other pills target storage symptoms. UroLift implants, Rezum steam, or iTind temporary device. Done in the office or as a quick outpatient visit. Aquablation, transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP), GreenLight, or holmium laser enucleation of the prostate (HoLEP). Done in the operating room, usually with one overnight stay or less. Removal of the inner prostate through the belly, often robotic. Reserved for very large glands.
Anesthesia & setting None. Home. None. Pills you take daily. Local or light sedation. Office or outpatient. Spinal or general anesthesia. Same-day or one night. General anesthesia. Typically 1 to 3 nights.
How well it works About 7 in 10 men with mild BPH stay stable over several years. Lifestyle moves can blunt symptoms but do not shrink the gland. Alpha blockers drop the IPSS score about 4 to 6 points within weeks. 5-ARIs add another 3 points over months. Combined, the effect is larger and progression to surgery drops sharply. IPSS improvement of about 7 to 11 points, durable to 5 years. Some men need a repeat procedure or new medicine over time. IPSS improvement around 13 to 15 points. Highly durable. Repeat surgery rates are very low. Excellent and durable symptom relief, similar to OR procedures, but with longer recovery.
Speed of relief Slow and variable. Lifestyle moves can take weeks to months. Days to weeks for alpha blockers and tadalafil. Months for 5-ARIs. UroLift: days. Rezum and iTind: a few weeks while tissue reshapes or shrinks. Weeks. Most men feel a clear difference within 4 to 6 weeks. Weeks to a couple of months.
Recovery time None. None. Back to normal activity in days. Some men have a catheter for a few days. Back to most activity in 1 to 2 weeks. Catheter for 1 to 5 days. 2 to 6 weeks. Catheter for about a week.
Reversible? Fully reversible. Fully reversible. Stop the pill, the effect fades within weeks to a few months. Mostly not reversible. UroLift implants can be removed if needed. Rezum and iTind change tissue you cannot put back. Not reversible. Tissue is permanently removed. Not reversible.
Sexual side effects None. Varies by pill. Some alpha blockers reduce or block ejaculation. 5-ARIs can lower libido or cause ED in a small share of men. Tadalafil helps erections. The best class for keeping ejaculation. UroLift and iTind preserve ejaculation in nearly all men. Rezum preserves it in most. Aquablation preserves ejaculation in most. TURP, GreenLight, and HoLEP cause retrograde (dry) ejaculation in most men. ED risk is low across this step. Retrograde ejaculation is common. ED risk is low to moderate.
Need to keep doing it? Yes. Lifestyle is daily and ongoing. Yes. Pills work only while you take them. Stop the pill and symptoms return within weeks. One-time treatment. A small share of men need a repeat or to add a pill within 5 years. One-time treatment. Very few men need a second procedure. One-time treatment.
Best fit when Symptoms are mild and not bothersome. IPSS under 8. No red flags (no retention, no infections, no kidney trouble). Symptoms bother you but are not severe. You are open to a daily pill. Your urologist sees no urgent reason to operate. You want a procedure but want to protect sexual function and avoid a hospital stay. Your prostate is small to mid-sized and the right shape. You want strong, durable relief. You are willing to accept retrograde ejaculation (or you pick Aquablation to lower that risk). Your prostate is mid-sized or large. Your prostate is very large (often over 100 grams) and your urologist offers this or refers you to a colleague who does.
Chapter 3 · Procedures up close

Within steps 3 and 4, you have a few choices

If your urologist suggests a procedure, you will often pick from two or three. They differ on size range, how much they spare your sex life, and how long they last.

Office procedures (step 3)

UroLiftImplants RezumSteam iTindTemporary device
How it works Tiny implants pull the prostate lobes apart to open the channel. Nothing is removed. Steam is injected into the prostate. The treated tissue is reabsorbed by your body over weeks. A small metal device is placed for 5 to 7 days, reshapes the channel, then is removed. Nothing stays inside.
Prostate size fit Smaller and mid-sized glands. Anatomy must be right (no large middle lobe in classic use). Small to mid-sized glands. Can treat a middle lobe. Smaller and mid-sized glands without an obstructing middle lobe.
How well it works IPSS improvement of about 7 to 11 points, durable to 5 years. IPSS improvement around 11 points at 5 years. The lowest 5-year repeat surgery rate of the office options. IPSS improvement around 9 points, durable in long-term cohorts.
Catheter after? Often none. Yes, for several days. Yes, while the device is in place.
Sexual function Erection and ejaculation preserved in the vast majority. Ejaculation preserved in most. Erections mostly preserved. Excellent preservation in studies. Often picked when this matters most.
Speed of relief Days. Several weeks (tissue has to shrink). About a week to a few weeks after removal.

Operating-room procedures (step 4)

AquablationRobot waterjet TURPCautery loop GreenLightLaser vaporization HoLEPLaser enucleation
How it works A robot uses ultrasound imaging to guide a high-pressure water jet that removes prostate tissue. An electric loop scrapes out tissue through a scope in the urethra. The long-standing reference procedure. A laser vaporizes prostate tissue. Less bleeding, so a common pick for men on blood thinners. A laser peels the inner prostate away from the outer shell. Removed pieces are pulled out through the bladder.
Prostate size fit Wide range, including larger glands (up to about 150 grams). Small to mid-sized glands, roughly 30 to 80 grams. Small to mid-sized glands, similar range to TURP. Any size, including very large glands. Many urologists prefer it for big prostates.
How well it works IPSS drops about 15 points at 5 years. Very low repeat rate. IPSS drops about 15 points. Highly durable. Similar to TURP. As good as or better than TURP, especially in large glands.
Hospital stay Same-day or one night. 1 to 2 nights. Same-day or one night. Same-day or one night.
Sexual function Retrograde ejaculation in about 1 in 14 men. ED risk low. Retrograde ejaculation in 1 in 2 to 3 in 4 men. ED in about 1 in 10. Retrograde ejaculation common, similar to TURP. Retrograde ejaculation in about 3 in 4 men. Erections largely preserved.
Bleeding / recovery Low to moderate. More bleeding than the laser options. A catheter with bladder irrigation flushes out clots at first. Some blood in the urine for days to a couple of weeks is normal, and a small share of men need a return visit for clots, or rarely a transfusion. Men on blood thinners are often steered to a laser. Low. Low.
Notable trade-off Newer technology. Not every center has it. Most widely available. Most data. Strong choice if you are on blood thinners. Best size range but a steeper learning curve. Not every urologist offers it.
One more option: prostatic artery embolization (PAE)

A special radiologist (one who works inside blood vessels) threads a tiny tube into the prostate's arteries and blocks blood flow. The gland then shrinks. It is an option for some men, mostly those who do not want or cannot have an OR procedure. The current urology guideline asks for a detailed discussion of the tradeoffs first. Long-term data are still being collected, and more men need a repeat than after TURP. Ask about it if the usual choices do not suit you.

Chapter 4 · The sexual side-effect question

How each treatment affects sex

This is the most common reason men hesitate. The risk varies by treatment, so the numbers below break it down by option.

Three things can change with BPH treatment, and they are easy to mix up:

  • Ejaculation. Some treatments push the semen back into the bladder instead of out. This is called retrograde, or "dry," ejaculation. It is not harmful. The feeling of orgasm is usually the same. It can affect fertility if you are trying to have a child.
  • Erections. A smaller group of men get new or worse erection trouble.
  • Libido. Some pills, mostly the 5-ARIs (pills that shrink the gland), can lower sex drive in a small group of men.

Side-by-side, from least to most ejaculatory impact

Ejaculation Erections
Watchful waiting No effect. No effect.
Tadalafil 5 mg daily No effect. Improved.
UroLift Preserved in nearly all men. Preserved in nearly all men.
iTind Preserved in nearly all men. Preserved.
Rezum Preserved in most. Mostly preserved.
Aquablation Retrograde in about 1 in 14. New ED in about 1 in 20.
Alpha blocker (tamsulosin, silodosin) Decreased volume or dry ejaculation is common. Generally preserved.
5-ARI (finasteride, dutasteride) Ejaculation problems in about 1 in 20 to 1 in 12. New ED in about 1 in 20 to 1 in 7. Libido drop in a small share. Most issues resolve if the medicine is stopped, but some men report lasting effects.
TURP, GreenLight, HoLEP Retrograde (dry) ejaculation in about 1 in 2 to 3 in 4 men. New ED in about 1 in 10 to 1 in 20.
Simple prostatectomy Retrograde is the norm. Preserved in most.
If protecting ejaculation is your top priority

Tell your urologist, because it changes the choice. UroLift, iTind, Rezum, and Aquablation are the four options that best preserve ejaculation. Each has its own trade-offs around prostate size and how long the result lasts. Your urologist will narrow these to the one or two that fit your anatomy.

Chapter 5 · Why size matters

Prostate size narrows your options

Different procedures work in different size ranges. Your urologist measures your prostate with an ultrasound or during a scope exam. The number changes which options stay on your list.

SizeProstate volume Options most often discussed
Under 30 grams UroLift, iTind, Rezum, TURP, GreenLight.
30 to 80 grams All of the above, plus Aquablation and HoLEP. This range has the most options.
80 to 150 grams HoLEP, Aquablation, or simple prostatectomy. Most office procedures stop being a good fit.
Over 150 grams HoLEP or simple prostatectomy.

The shape of the gland also matters. A large lobe pushing up into the bladder (a "middle lobe") can rule out UroLift and iTind even when the size is in range. Your urologist checks for this on the scope exam.

Chapter 6 · Your trade-offs

What you are weighing

The right choice depends on what you most want to protect. Ask yourself:

  • How much do my symptoms bother me right now? (The IPSS score helps put a number on this.)
  • How much do I want to keep ejaculation the way it is?
  • How much do I want to avoid a daily pill?
  • How much recovery time can I afford?
  • Do I want one fix that lasts, or do I prefer a lighter one that may need a repeat in 5 to 10 years?
  • How much does going under or a night in the hospital weigh on me?
  • If I take a daily pill, will I take it every day?
  • If I still want a child, does fertility need a role here?
You can move up a step later

Picking watchful waiting or pills does not lock you in. If your symptoms get worse, every step above stays available. Many men spend years on step one or two and then move up when they want to. Picking a procedure does close off some options, since tissue removed cannot be put back.

Chapter 7 · Take these to your appointment

Good questions to ask your urologist

Print this page, or write these down. The space at the bottom is for your own questions.

  1. Given my IPSS score, my prostate size, and the shape of my prostate, which options are a good fit for me, and which are not?
  2. If I do nothing right now, how likely is it that my symptoms get worse over the next few years?
  3. If you are recommending one treatment over another, what is the main reason?
  4. What will happen to my ejaculation after this option, in your hands and at this center? What about my erections?
  5. How long does this treatment usually last before another one might be needed?
  6. How long will I have a catheter, and what should I plan for during recovery?
  7. Do you offer all of the options we are discussing, or would you refer me out for one of them?

My own questions:

Where this information comes from

  1. American Urological Association Guideline Amendment on the Management of Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia / Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms, 2023.
  2. McConnell JD, et al. The long-term effect of doxazosin, finasteride, and combination therapy on clinical progression of BPH (MTOPS). New England Journal of Medicine, 2003.
  3. Roehrborn CG, et al. Five-year results of the prospective randomized controlled prostatic urethral lift study (LIFT).
  4. McVary KT, et al. Five-year results of water vapor thermal therapy (Rezum) for moderate-to-severe BPH-LUTS.
  5. Gilling P, et al. WATER and WATER II trials of Aquablation therapy, 5-year outcomes.
  6. Chughtai B, et al. Long-term outcomes of the temporary implantable nitinol device (iTind).
  7. WellPrept clinical brief: Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH), 2026-05-05 build.
This decision aid does not recommend one option over another. The numbers above reflect typical published ranges; your prostate, your anatomy, and your health may make some options more or less appropriate. Your urologist is the right person to translate this material to your situation.

WellPrept Decision Aid · bph-treatment-choice · v1 · next review 2027-05-24