Decision Aid
Stress urinary incontinence: how to choose
You leak with a cough, a sneeze, a laugh, or when you exercise. Your urologist has explained that four treatments are on the table. This page compares the four on how well they work, what they ask of you, and what recovery looks like.
Reviewed by David Canes, MD
Updated 2026-06-05
Reading time ~8 min
Print-friendly
A note before you start
This tool does not pick for you. Your urologist or urogynecologist will help you choose.
Use this page to sort out your thoughts before your visit. Use it to ask sharper questions during it. Stress incontinence is one of the most common things women come to the office for. No single option is best for every woman. For the full picture of what stress incontinence is and why it happens, read the stress urinary incontinence patient guide.
Chapter 1 · The decision
What this decision is about
You have stress urinary incontinence. That means you leak urine when something pushes on your bladder from above, such as a cough, a sneeze, a laugh, a jump, or a lift. The leak is small to moderate, you know it is coming, and you do not feel a strong urge right before it.
Your urologist or urogynecologist has done the workup and ruled out things that would change the plan. Now four treatments are in front of you, and the choice belongs to you.
The four are pelvic floor physical therapy, a vaginal pessary, urethral bulking, and a midurethral sling. They are ordered here from least to most invasive. Pelvic floor therapy needs no procedure at all, the sling is an operation, and the pessary and bulking sit in between.
What your doctor brings to the choice
Your doctor has already done the work to make sure stress leakage is what you have. That means a careful history, a pelvic exam, a cough test (you cough and they look for the leak), a urine test to rule out infection, and a check that your bladder empties well. If you also feel a sudden urge to go and leak on the way to the bathroom, that is a different pattern (called urge or overactive bladder). Many women have both. If you have both, the choices below still apply to the stress side. Your doctor will tell you which side to treat first or whether to treat both at once.
Who this aid is for
You have leakage with effort, and your doctor has confirmed that is the main pattern. You do not have a large prolapse that needs its own repair, and your bladder empties well. If your situation does not match this, the four options below still apply in some form, but your doctor may add steps to the plan and will go over them with you.
Chapter 2 · Your options
Compare the four paths
The columns are arranged from least to most invasive, not by preference. Read down a column to learn an option. Read across a row to compare them on one thing.
A note on where to start
You do not have to try the options in order. Some women start with pelvic floor therapy because that is what fits. Others come in and tell their doctor they have already tried Kegels for years and are ready for a sling. Both choices are reasonable. The order here is only a way to lay the options out, and you can start with any one of them.
Chapter 3 · The honest disagreements
Where doctors genuinely disagree
Two thoughtful doctors can look at the same patient and pick a different path. These are the points where they split:
The mesh question
If you have heard scary stories about mesh, ask your doctor about them. About 15 years ago, a different mesh product was used to repair pelvic organ prolapse. That product was placed in a larger sheet, in a different part of the pelvis, and it caused serious problems for many women. In 2019, the FDA pulled that prolapse mesh product from the US market.
The midurethral sling is a different product. It is much smaller (a thin tape), placed in a different position (under the middle of the urethra), for a different problem (stress leakage, not prolapse). It has its own long-term safety record. Major urology and urogynecology groups around the world, including the international continence community, continue to call the midurethral sling a standard, well-studied treatment for stress incontinence. It is also still on the US market.
None of that means it is the right choice for every woman. If you have decided you do not want any synthetic tape in your body, tell your doctor. The non-mesh options for surgery are urethral bulking and, in some practices, an older surgery called a Burch suspension or a sling made from your own tissue. Ask your doctor which non-mesh options they offer.
Should every woman try pelvic floor therapy first?
Many doctors believe every woman with stress leakage should give pelvic floor therapy a fair try before any procedure. Their argument: it is free of risk, it builds skills that help for life, and it works for many women. Other doctors point out that for some women, the leakage is severe, the cause is clearly anatomic, and months of exercises will not change that. They lean toward an early conversation about a procedure for those women, especially when leakage is keeping them from exercise, work, or sleep. Both views are reasonable. Ask your doctor where you fall in their thinking and why.
Bulking or sling as a first procedure?
The sling has higher long-term success and is more durable. The bulking injection has a lower success rate and may need touch-ups. But it skips the operating room and the recovery. Some doctors strongly favor the sling for most women, because they would rather do one durable treatment than a series of touch-ups. Other doctors favor bulking as the first procedure. They lean that way for older women, women on blood thinners, women with other major medical issues, or women who simply want to avoid the operating room. Both views are well-supported in the literature. Your doctor's read on your situation matters more than a general rule.
Retropubic versus transobturator sling
There are two main ways to place a midurethral sling. The retropubic route goes up behind the pubic bone. The transobturator route goes out through the groin. Both work. The retropubic route has slightly higher long-term cure rates and slightly more risk of trouble emptying the bladder afterward. The transobturator route has fewer bladder-emptying issues and slightly more risk of groin pain. Many surgeons prefer one or the other strongly. If a sling is on your list, ask which one your surgeon does most often and why.
The woman with a complicated pelvic history
Prior pelvic surgery, prior pelvic radiation, a previous sling, or significant urethral changes from low estrogen all change the choice. None of the four options is off the table, but the right one for you may be different from the general patterns above. Your doctor (often a urogynecologist or a urologist who focuses on female pelvic medicine) is the right person to walk through how your history shifts the choice. If the plan still feels unclear, ask for a second opinion.
Chapter 4 · Your trade-offs
What you are weighing
No single option is best for every woman. As you read the table, ask yourself:
- How much is the leakage affecting my life right now? My exercise, my sleep, my work, my social life, my sex life?
- Am I willing and able to do a daily home program for several weeks, with weekly visits to a PT?
- Am I okay with putting in and taking out a device myself, into my own vagina?
- How do I feel about a procedure in an office? In an operating room?
- How do I feel about a small piece of synthetic tape staying in my body for the long term?
- How important is one-and-done versus a treatment I might need to repeat?
- Do I still hope to have a future pregnancy? (If yes, most doctors lean against a sling for now.)
- Do I have other pelvic floor issues, such as urge symptoms, prolapse, or postpartum recovery? These can change which option fits best.
- If I tried the option that asks the least of me first, and it did not work, would I be willing to move on to a more involved one?
You can move to another option later
Trying pelvic floor therapy first does not close off any other option. If you start with a pessary and decide you would rather have something more permanent, you can. If you have urethral bulking and the effect fades, a sling is still on the table. You are picking where to start.
Chapter 5 · Take these to your appointment
Good questions to ask
Print this page or write these down. Ask the ones that fit your situation. The space at the bottom is for your own questions.
For your doctor
- Is my leakage pure stress incontinence, or do I have some urge leakage too? If it is mixed, which side do you think we should treat first?
- Given how much my leakage is affecting my life, where would you start if you were me?
- Do you have a pelvic floor physical therapist you trust and refer to?
- If I want to try a pessary, do you fit them in your office? How long would I try one before deciding whether to keep going with it?
- Do you offer urethral bulking? If yes, what do you tell your patients to expect at one year and at five years?
- If I lean toward a sling, do you place retropubic or transobturator slings, or both? Which one do you do most often, and why?
- What is your own complication rate for slings? How often does a patient of yours need a second procedure?
- If I want a non-mesh surgical option, what do you offer? Would you refer me to a urogynecologist who does autologous slings or a Burch suspension?
- How does my plan to have (or not have) a future pregnancy change what you recommend?
- If we try option A first and it does not work, what is option B and how soon could we move to it?
My own questions:
Where this information comes from
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Urinary incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse in women: management. NG123. Updated 2023.
- Dumoulin C, Cacciari LP, Hay-Smith EJC. Pelvic floor muscle training versus no treatment, or inactive control treatments, for urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2018.
- Lipp A, Shaw C, Glavind K. Mechanical devices for urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2014.
- Kirchin V, Page T, Keegan PE, et al. Urethral injection therapy for urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017.
- International Continence Society. Standardisation of terminology of lower urinary tract function. Neurourology and Urodynamics, ongoing committee opinions.
- Ford AA, Rogerson L, Cody JD, Aluko P, Ogah JA. Mid-urethral sling operations for stress urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017.
- Mostafa A, Lim CP, Hopper L, Madhuvrata P, Abdel-Fattah M. Single-incision mini-slings versus standard midurethral slings in surgical management of female stress urinary incontinence: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis. European Urology, 2014 with subsequent long-term follow-up reports.
- US Food and Drug Administration. FDA takes action to protect women's health, orders manufacturers of surgical mesh intended for transvaginal repair of pelvic organ prolapse to stop selling all devices. FDA Statement, April 2019. (Note: this 2019 action applied to transvaginal mesh for prolapse, not to midurethral sling tape for stress incontinence.)
This decision aid does not recommend one option over another. Outcome numbers reflect typical published ranges; your own anatomy, history, and goals may make some options more or less appropriate. Your urologist or urogynecologist is the right person to translate this material to your situation.
WellPrept Decision Aid · female-sui-treatment-choice · v1 · next review 2027-06-05