Decision Aid
Kidney stones: which procedure?
When a stone needs to come out, there is often more than one way to do it. This page compares the four paths on how well they work, how long recovery takes, and what can go wrong.
Last reviewed 2026-05-23
Reading time ~6 min
Print-friendly
A note before you start
This tool does not pick for you. Your urologist will help you choose.
Use this page to sort out your thoughts beforehand and to ask sharper questions during your visit. Your urologist knows your stone and your body, and can fit these options to your case.
Chapter 1 · The decision
What this decision is about
Most small kidney stones pass on their own. Stones under about 5 mm usually pass with fluids, pain pills, and time. This page is for a different case. Your urologist has decided you need a procedure. That often means the stone is too big to pass, is blocking the kidney, is causing an infection, or is causing pain that will not stop.
There are three main procedures, and in some cases you can also keep watching and waiting. Each path takes a different route into the body, with its own mix of success, recovery, and risk.
Where your urologist's judgment leads
Your urologist weighs several things together: the size of your stone, where it sits, what it is made of (if that is known), the shape of your kidney and ureter, how well your kidneys work, whether there is an infection, and your overall health. From that, they will tell you which options below fit your stone. This page is for when more than one of them fits your stone.
Chapter 2 · Your options
Compare the four main paths
Columns are arranged from least to most invasive, not by preference.
A note on lasers (URS)
You may hear about two lasers used during ureteroscopy. The older one is holmium:YAG, and the newer one is the thulium fiber laser. Both break up stones well. The thulium fiber laser has been catching on since the early 2020s, and at some settings it can make finer fragments, though long-term outcomes are still being studied. It is not yet the set standard, and both are reasonable choices. Which one your urologist uses depends on what their center has and how they were trained.
Chapter 3 · The honest disagreements
Where urologists genuinely disagree
Two doctors can look at the same stone and pick a different path:
- "Dust" or "fragment and basket" during URS. Either approach works. The pick depends on training and tools. Basketing usually gets a piece back for stone analysis, which can guide prevention.
- Whether to place a ureteral stent after a simple URS. Some always stent. Some stent only when needed. Both ways are backed by guidelines.
- SWL vs URS for a 1–1.5 cm kidney stone. Both are fine. The pick often comes down to which one a practice is set up to do well.
- How hard to chase tiny leftover bits after a procedure. Some urologists aim for fully stone-free. Some accept very small bits. Leftover bits can grow or pass later, so ask what your urologist is aiming for.
When you are weighing two options, ask your urologist which one they would pick and why for your case.
Not every urologist offers every option
Training and tools vary by doctor. Most general urologists offer URS, and many community centers also offer SWL. PCNL is often done by urologists who do a lot of stone surgery, which sometimes means a larger center. If your urologist does not do the option you want, they will say so and may send you to a partner who does.
Chapter 4 · Your trade-offs
What you are weighing
No single procedure is best for every patient. As you read the table, ask yourself:
- How much do I want to skip an incision or general anesthesia? Even if it means a longer or less sure path?
- How much do I want to be done in one procedure? Or am I okay if I might need a second one?
- How fast do I need to be back at work or active?
- How much does a temporary stent bother me?
- If my stone is large, how do I feel about the longer PCNL recovery? Or should we try a smaller procedure first?
Chapter 5 · Take these to your appointment
Good questions to ask your urologist
Print this page or write these down. The space at the bottom is for your own questions.
- Given my stone size, where it sits, and (if known) what it is made of, which options fit me and which do not?
- If you suggest one option over another, what is the main reason?
- What stone-free rate should I expect from your pick, in your hands, at this center?
- If I get a stent afterward, when will it come out? What should I expect to feel until then?
- What is the chance I will need a second procedure? How would we decide that?
My own questions:
Where this information comes from
- European Association of Urology Guidelines on Urolithiasis, 2024 edition. Sections 3.4 through 3.4.6.
- Pearle MS, Goldfarb DS, Assimos DG, et al. Medical management of kidney stones. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2014.
- Kronenberg P, Traxer O. Update on lasers in urology 2022: current and new advanced lithotripsy techniques. European Urology Focus, 2022.
- WellPrept clinical brief: Kidney Stones (Urolithiasis / Nephrolithiasis), 2026-05-04 build.
This decision aid does not recommend one option over another. Outcome numbers reflect typical published ranges; your specific stone and anatomy may make some options more or less appropriate. Your urologist is the right person to translate this material to your situation.
WellPrept Decision Aid · kidney-stones-procedure-choice · v2 · next review 2027-05-23